# Comparison of ASME B16.34 and API 600 Standards for Valve Design and Manufacturing
Introduction
In the world of industrial valves, two standards dominate the landscape: ASME B16.34 and API 600. These specifications provide critical guidelines for valve design, manufacturing, and testing, ensuring safety, reliability, and performance in demanding applications. While both standards address similar concerns, they have distinct focuses and applications that engineers must understand when specifying valves for different industries.
Scope and Application
ASME B16.34 is a broader standard that covers the design, materials, dimensions, and testing requirements for flanged, threaded, and welding end valves. It applies to various valve types including gate, globe, check, ball, and butterfly valves made from materials like carbon steel, stainless steel, and alloy steels.
API 600, on the other hand, specifically focuses on bolted bonnet steel gate valves for petroleum and natural gas industries. It’s more specialized than ASME B16.34 and includes additional requirements for materials, design, and testing that are particularly relevant to oil and gas applications.
Key Differences in Design Requirements
Pressure-Temperature Ratings
ASME B16.34 provides comprehensive pressure-temperature ratings for valves based on material groups and classes. These ratings are determined through rigorous testing and form the basis for valve selection across various industries.
API 600 incorporates the pressure-temperature ratings from ASME B16.34 but adds specific requirements for gate valves used in hydrocarbon services. The standard mandates additional design features like extended bonnets for cryogenic service or graphited packing for high-temperature applications.
Wall Thickness
One significant difference lies in the minimum wall thickness requirements. API 600 typically requires thicker walls compared to ASME B16.34 for the same pressure class, providing an additional safety margin for the demanding conditions in oil and gas operations.
Manufacturing and Testing Requirements
Material Specifications
ASME B16.34 references material specifications primarily from ASTM standards, while API 600 includes additional material requirements from API specifications. API 600 also imposes more stringent controls on material traceability and certification.
Testing Protocols
Both standards require pressure testing, but API 600 mandates more extensive testing including:
- Shell tests at 1.5 times the rated pressure
- Seat tests at 1.1 times the rated pressure
- Additional tests for high-pressure closures
- Optional fire testing per API 607/6FA
Industry Applications
ASME B16.34 valves are widely used across multiple industries including power generation, chemical processing, water treatment, and general industrial applications. The standard’s broader scope makes it suitable for diverse operating conditions.
API 600 valves are specifically designed for the oil and gas industry, particularly in:
- Upstream production facilities
- Refineries
- Pipeline systems
- Petrochemical plants
Conclusion
While ASME B16.34 and API 600 share some common ground in valve design principles, they serve different purposes in industrial applications. ASME B16.34 provides fundamental requirements applicable to a wide range of valves, whereas API 600 adds specialized
Keyword: two commonly asme b16 34 and api 600